My first choice would not be running a Pro-Style offense with this group of kids but I will say that it could work under the right coach. At least we could be more successful than we are now. There are different ways to find mismatches and get your athletes in space in a Pro-Style offense just not as many as in a Spread Offense. And of course that is my opinion.
The problem is moreso Miller. He coaches in a box under certain perimeters. In other words, he has the NFL playbook, he just has zero idea of how to implement it with different talent. Yeah, execution works when you have a coach at QB who is 6'4" with a rocket arm in Curt Warner and a group of WR's that consists of Pat Fitzgerald, Anquon Boldin, and Stevie Breaston. Oh yeah, and an NFL offensive line. That is the big difference with the NFL to college. The league has implemented rules that favor the Pro-Style offense with 40 year old statues at QB. On top of that these QB's have logged lots of miles at the position and really are "coaches on the field" who can send the slot into motion and back to figure out if the defense is in 2-under man coverage and then run off the corner with #1 WR and exploit a LB in the flat with a speed out. The Pro QB makes all the reads and checks at the LOS. In college you still have teams freezing at the LOS and checking with the sideline because a coach in the box sees those things.
I think Jimmy has a good arm and gets the ball out quick. But man it was nice to see a QB like Barr use his legs rather than getting barbecued on every pass play. Even the Duquesne QB is not a speed demon or huge run threat but our DE's HAD to respect him on zone read which goes back to my whole easier to defend 10 than 11. BobbyMo is 100% correct. Opposing DC's lick their chops watching us on film. In all my years of football I've never seen a more scoutable offense at this level.
Zone into the boundary, speed out, followed by some sort of deeper stick route. That is our offense. Early in the game we usually run 1 screen into the boundary on a 3rd and long but that has been snuffed out. And since week one teams have figured out we will take a couple one on one backside shots to Allison. That has been our offense.
I said it before and will say it again, two many square pegs trying to be fit into round holes. As great as Vecchio, Madison, Anu, and Robinson are they are 5'10, 5'9, 5'8, 5'8 respectively. We do have two good TE's and Gonzo played a lot of WR in HS. Why are we not moving Gonzo around AND keeping Reggie in the game? No offense to Jon Wanat but we have tendencies every time he enters the game. If you really want to trick dick a defense, even running a Pro-Style offense, you line Gonzalez up at TE, HB, WR, Slot, Wing which takes away a lot of tendencies. Ah well what do I know? I never coached in the NFL.